Back to Forests
Jul 09, 2025
5 min read

“What If the Resurrection Is the Most Rational Claim in History?”

Exploring the historical and philosophical case for the resurrection of Jesus as the cornerstone of a coherent worldview.
Naturalism Part 5 of 7

For a lot of people, the resurrection of Jesus sounds like a religious fairy tale — a nice story that offers hope to people who need something to believe in.

But what if that’s a misread?

What if the resurrection isn’t a sentimental myth…
but a historical event with real evidence and unavoidable implications?

What if it’s not just possible
but the best explanation for the way the world actually is?


Start with the Basics — What Would You Expect?**

Let’s set religion aside for a moment.

Imagine someone rose from the dead in actual history — not in legend, not in metaphor, not in imagination.

What would you expect to see?

  • Eyewitnesses who claimed to see him — and didn’t change their story under pressure
  • A body that was never produced, even by the enemies
  • A movement that exploded out of fear, not power
  • Skeptics who became followers
  • A story too counterintuitive to be propaganda
  • A message too early to be legend

Now compare that to the actual historical record:

  • The tomb was empty.
  • The disciples went from terrified deserters to bold preachers, facing persecution and death.
  • The first witnesses were women — culturally inconvenient, not something you’d fabricate.
  • The accounts circulated during the lifetime of hostile witnesses.
  • The movement exploded in the exact city where the body would’ve been easiest to disprove.

And scholars across the spectrum — even skeptical ones — agree on several “minimal facts”:

  • Jesus was crucified.
  • His tomb was empty.
  • His followers believed they saw him alive again.
  • The church began almost immediately and at great cost.

The question isn’t whether something happened.
The question is: what explains it best?


The Alternatives Don’t Really Work**

Let’s look at the common naturalistic explanations:

“The disciples made it up.”

But why would they die for something they knew was false?
Liars make terrible martyrs.

“It was a legend that developed over time.”

But the resurrection claims were circulating within months, not centuries.
That’s not how legends work. That’s how news works.

“They hallucinated.”

Hallucinations are private, not group experiences.
They’re not physical. They don’t eat meals with you.
They don’t appear over 40 days to 500+ people.

“The body was stolen.”

By who? The disciples who were hiding in fear? The Roman guards?
None of the motives add up — and nobody produced the body, even when Christianity was exploding.

None of these theories explain all the facts.
Most only explain one or two — and require more faith than the resurrection itself.

So maybe…
just maybe…
the original explanation was right.

“He is not here. He is risen.”


The Resurrection Doesn’t Just Explain One Event — It Explains Reality**

This isn’t just about something that happened 2,000 years ago.
It’s about why anything today makes sense.

Because if Jesus rose from the dead:

  • Then death isn’t the end — it’s a door.
  • Then truth isn’t fragile — it’s embodied.
  • Then meaning isn’t a projection — it’s a Person.
  • Then hope isn’t sentimental — it’s grounded.
  • Then love isn’t random — it’s real, and it won.

The resurrection makes sense of why:

  • We ache for justice, even when it costs us.
  • We sense that beauty means something.
  • We long for more than survival.
  • We believe that good should defeat evil.
  • We keep hoping, even when everything falls apart.

It’s not just a claim. It’s a key.
And when you use it, the rest of the world starts to unlock.


This Isn’t a Guilt Trip. It’s an Invitation.**

No one’s asking you to believe this just because it’s “what Christians believe.”
That’s not how faith works — not the kind that lasts.

The resurrection is a claim you can:

  • Study historically
  • Investigate intellectually
  • Weigh philosophically
  • Experience personally

It has stood for centuries — not because it’s emotionally comforting, but because it’s shockingly coherent.

Not just religiously.
Existentially.

It explains what no other worldview can:

  • Why you exist
  • What love is
  • Why evil feels wrong
  • Why death isn’t satisfying
  • And why something in you refuses to let go of hope

A Story Big Enough for You

You don’t have to be ready to accept everything right now.
You don’t have to say “yes” to every doctrine or belief system or label.

But be honest:

If this happened…
If a man really died and came back — not as a ghost or a hallucination but as the firstborn of a new kind of life

Then what else might be true?

Next time, we’ll talk about you.

Because if this story is real —
and you’re not just a chemical accident —
then the next question is personal:

What kind of life is possible now?

Naturalism Series

  1. Part 1
    “Science Isn’t a Worldview. But You’re Using It Like One.”
    “Why science alone can’t answer life’s biggest questions.”
  2. Part 2
    “The Universe Runs on Code. So Who Wrote the Syntax?”
    “Exploring the implications of information systems in biology and the question of their origin.”
  3. Part 3
    “Naturalism Isn’t Neutral. It’s Just Small.”
    Naturalism claims to be a neutral, fact-based worldview. But in reality, it’s a small story that cuts off the deepest parts of being human.
  4. Part 4
    “Faith Isn’t Blind. It’s the Foundation of Everything.”
    Everyone has faith. The real question is: What is your faith built on?
  5. Part 5
    “What If the Resurrection Is the Most Rational Claim in History?”
    Exploring the historical and philosophical case for the resurrection of Jesus as the cornerstone of a coherent worldview.
  6. Part 6
    “You’re Not a Brain in a Jar. So Now What?”
    Exploring the historical and philosophical case for the resurrection of Jesus as the cornerstone of a coherent worldview.
  7. Part 7
    “Live Like It’s True - A Framework for Following Jesus When You’re Just Starting Out.”
    Exploring how to live out the Christian faith authentically when you're new to it.